Magnus Carlsen’s controversial forfeits spark domino effect! Two more GMs skip games at Total Chess Pilot | Chess News


Magnus Carlsen's controversial forfeits spark domino effect! Two more GMs skip games at Total Chess Pilot
Magnus Carlsen, Richard Rapport, and Abhimanyu Mishra

World No. 1 Magnus Carlsen‘s decision to forfeit his Fast Classic games after securing unassailable leads has triggered a domino effect at the Total Chess World Championship Tour Pilot, with two more Grandmasters choosing to skip their matches on Wednesday.India’s R Vaishali and Armenia’s Haik Martirosyan were left waiting in the playing hall after their respective opponents, Abhimanyu Mishra and Richard Rapport, decided not to turn up for the concluding Fast Classic games. The developments came after Carlsen had courted controversy by walking away from his matches against Kazakhstan’s Bibisara Assaubayeva on consecutive days.While Carlsen’s actions had already raised questions about sportsmanship and the tournament’s regulations, the decisions by Mishra and Rapport have added another layer to the debate over the format.

Mishra explains decision after Vaishali is handed eight points

Competing for places 21st to 24th, 17-year-old Mishra entered the final game with an 11-1 lead over Vaishali after winning the opening day’s fixture 13-7. He had also secured the second day’s match before the Fast Classic encounter, having built an advantage through the blitz and rapid games.Mishra chose not to play the concluding contest, handing Vaishali all eight points on offer. However, his 11-9 victory in the day’s overall score meant he won the tie and advanced.“There’s nothing to say,” Vaishali said as she walked away from the playing area.She will now face Uzbekistan’s Nodirbek Abdusattorov in a match to avoid finishing last in the tournament.Mishra later took to X to explain his decision, citing fatigue after an exhausting schedule and uncertainty over whether the remaining games in already-decided matches would count towards players’ ratings.“There’s nothing to say” was Vaishali’s brief reaction, while Mishra said he had approached the chief arbiter well in advance to seek permission not to play.“Well in advance of the next game, I approached the chief arbiter to ask whether it would be acceptable for me not to show up. She told me that the decision was entirely mine and that it was perfectly acceptable not to play,” he wrote.He added that the demanding schedule, coupled with uncertainty surrounding the rating implications of the remaining games, had influenced his decision.“Given that uncertainty, combined with the fatigue I felt, plus permission from the chief arbiter, I had sufficient reasons not to show up,” Mishra said.

Rapport also skips game after losing tie

Rapport’s decision came in a different context. The Hungarian Grandmaster had already lost his tie against Martirosyan and was trailing 2-10 on the second day after conceding the opening day’s fixture 9-11.He subsequently forfeited the Fast Classic game, leaving Martirosyan without an opponent for the concluding encounter.The two walkovers followed Carlsen’s repeated decision to skip the final game against Assaubayeva after taking commanding leads in their two-day tie.

Carlsen’s actions put tournament format under scrutiny

Carlsen had already secured an 11-point advantage on the opening day against Assaubayeva after winning three of the four blitz games and two rapid games. He then forfeited the Fast Classic encounter, handing his opponent all eight points on offer, but still won the day’s fixture 11.5-8.5.The Norwegian repeated the move on Wednesday after building a 10-2 lead through the blitz and rapid games. Assaubayeva was again awarded the eight points, leaving the day’s score tied 10-10. Carlsen, however, advanced on the strength of his opening-day victory.Explaining his decision, Carlsen said the concluding game had little significance once the match was decided.“There will be no classical game as I understood, the match is over. The only consequence of not showing up is that you will lose a totally meaningless game,” he was quoted as saying by Norwegian broadcaster TV2.Carlsen also admitted that he was not keen on playing more classical chess in the classification fixture.“This is an awkward situation to be in, I would rather not play that much more classical anymore,” he had said on Tuesday.The Norwegian’s decision attracted criticism, with American Grandmaster Hans Niemann alleging preferential treatment and insisting that the rules should be applied equally to all players. FIDE Chief Executive Adviser Emil Sutovsky described the conduct as unsportsmanlike, while India’s Olympiad captain Srinath Narayanan also criticised the lack of courtesy.

Organisers looking at feedback ahead of 2027 edition

The controversy has also put the spotlight on the tournament’s regulations, particularly the significance of Fast Classic games after a player has already secured qualification.Total Chess CEO Kjell Madland said the Budapest pilot was intended to help organisers assess the format and identify possible refinements before the inaugural edition in March 2027.“The Budapest pilot is an important learning exercise for Total Chess. While we have developed the format and regulations with considerable thought and input, the real test is how they work in a live competitive environment,” Madland said in a statement.He added that organisers wanted feedback directly from players and arbiters before deciding whether changes were necessary.The organisers had not immediately confirmed whether Carlsen’s forfeits would attract an automatic fine. With Mishra and Rapport now also having skipped their concluding games, the issue has become more pressing: whether the format needs clearer rules to ensure that every scheduled game is treated consistently, irrespective of whether a match has already been decided.



Source link

Raj
Author: Raj

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *